π
Grade 4 Social Studies Β· World 4: A New Government Β· Level 29
The Great Compromise
Explain how big and small states settled on a House based on population and a Senate with two per state.
Warm-up, learn, try it together, practice, then a quick check. About 15 minutes.
What children learn in Level 29
- The biggest fight was over votes in Congress. Under the Virginia Plan, states with more people would get more votes. Big states loved it.
- Under the New Jersey Plan, every state would get one equal vote. Small states wanted that, because they feared being outvoted.
- The Convention nearly broke apart. When one key vote came up, Abraham Baldwin of Georgia switched sides and made it a tie, which kept the talks alive.
- The answer was a compromise, an agreement where each side gives up something. Congress would have two houses. In the House of Representatives, seats depend on population. In the Senate, every state has two.
- Here are the seats in the first Congress. A bill needs both houses to pass, so big and small states each have a say. That's the Great Compromise.
Georgia Standards of Excellence in Social Studies:
- SS4H2.b β Evaluate the major issues debated at the Constitutional Convention: the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation, the rights of states to govern themselves (federal system), the Great Compromise, and slavery (Three-Fifths Compromise).
- IPS.3 β Information Processing Skill 3: identify issues and/or problems and alternative solutions (developing in Grade 4)